Church.”133 Implicit in these words is a third argument—the argument from the plausibility of effects within the early church. It can be formulated as follows: If a saying or deed attributed to Jesus is contextually plausible, coherent with other evidence about Jesus, and continuous with or provides a plausible cause for the practice and belief of the early church, then it is reasonable to conclude that the evidence in question is historical. In other words, if a saying or deed of Jesus not only
Page 41